MarketNovember 11, 2026

Florida has 215,000 listings and nearly half have cut their price. Here is how I price a house into that.

Florida holds roughly 15 percent of all active U.S. listings on a fraction of the national housing stock, and nearly 45 percent have already reduced their price. How I price a house into that shelf, and what I tell buyers who now have choices.

Divina Greenberg, J.D., CIPS · Florida Real Estate Broker

People keep asking me whether this is a good time to sell. This week the answer starts with two numbers, and neither one is a forecast.

Florida is carrying more than 215,000 active residential listings, roughly 15 percent of every listing in the United States, in a state that holds a much smaller fraction of the national housing stock. Nearly 45 percent of those listings have already reduced their price.

I have been a broker here since 2004, and I built fourteen homes in Manatee County between 2015 and 2023, so I have watched this market from both the listing side and the construction side. What those two numbers say to me is simple. A listing count tells you how many houses are for sale. A price-reduction rate tells you how many of them are priced at a number the market has stopped agreeing to. When both are high, the problem is not a shortage of buyers. The problem is price.

Why the shelf got so deep

Florida sat at the front of the pandemic migration, and the construction that followed is now delivering finished houses into a buyer pool that is thinner than the one those homes were planned for. Three things thinned it. Insurance repriced dramatically. A homeowner sitting on a three percent mortgage has almost no reason to move. And the buyers who are still here can see, plainly, that they have choices.

I have been through enough cycles to recognize the shape of this one. It is not a collapse. It is the market returning to something closer to ordinary after several years of the opposite, and ordinary is uncomfortable for anyone who bought the top of the last one.

What I tell a seller right now

The comparable sale from eighteen months ago is not your comparable. It is a record of a different market, with fewer competing houses and a buyer with more urgency than the person walking through your kitchen today.

  • Price to the last sale that actually closed recently, not the highest one your neighborhood ever posted.
  • Be the best-priced house on your street rather than the best house at the top of your street's range. A buyer with 215,000 options compares price first.
  • If a reduction is coming, take it in the first two weeks. Early cuts read as a market adjustment. Cuts in week eight read as a problem, and buyers start waiting for the next one.
  • Condition and paperwork decide the tie. When four houses on one street are all reduced, the one with the newer roof, the clean inspection and an insurance quote in hand is the one that closes.

What I tell a buyer

The leverage has come back, and it is not a rumor.

Ask for what you actually need — repairs, closing costs, a rate buydown. In a thinner market those requests get answered. Keep your inspection and insurance contingencies; a seller in this market is far more likely to grant them than to lose the contract. And do not mistake a motivated seller for a bargain. A reduced price on a house with an uninsurable roof or a failing seawall is not a discount, it is a deposit on a problem.

Get the insurance quote before the contract. In Florida the second negotiation happens once coverage is priced, and it can cost more than the price cut you won.

How this looks in our two counties

Manatee and north Sarasota carry the statewide picture with their own distortions. New construction competes directly with resale in Parrish and Lakewood Ranch, and a builder can offer incentives a private seller cannot match. Impact fee litigation in Manatee keeps the cost of the next new house uncertain, which pushes some buyers back toward existing homes, while insurance pricing pushes others out of the market entirely.

The translation for this corner of the Gulf coast: inventory is real, reductions are common, and the houses that sell are priced honestly for a buyer who has choices.

Where I land

215,000 listings and a 45 percent reduction rate is not the end of the Florida market. It is a market that has stopped rewarding optimism about price. Sellers who price to today's numbers sell. The ones waiting for the number their neighbor got in 2022 are the ones making up the 45 percent.

If you want to know what your house is actually competing against, that is a conversation about specific addresses rather than statewide percentages. Bring me the address and I will show you the shelf you are on.