The homestead exemption grew. The insurance bill grew faster.
Amendment 3 expands the homestead exemption and caps non-homestead assessment increases from 2027. I am glad it passed, and I am still telling every buyer to budget as if the savings never arrive.
Divina Greenberg, J.D., CIPS · Florida Real Estate Broker
I voted for Amendment 3 and I am glad it passed. I am also the person who has to sit across the closing table from a buyer and explain why the number on their mortgage statement may not fall the way they expect.
What the amendment actually does
Two things happen, and they happen at different moments.
The homestead exemption expands. That is real money, and it lands on the tax bill of every owner who has a homestead exemption on the property.
The cap on non-homestead assessment increases is the second half, and it matters to a great many people in this market: the snowbird with a condo on Longboat, the parent holding a rental for a child at New College, the investor with three doors in south Manatee. Their assessed value has been allowed to climb faster than a homestead owner's, and this slows that climb.
Both changes start with the 2027 tax year. Not this one. Anyone buying between now and then will close under current rules.
Where the savings go
Here is the part I want every client to hear clearly. A tax cut is only a cut if the other line items on the same bill hold still, and in this market they have not held still.
Insurance is the line I watch. It is not a soft number that follows inflation politely. A single renewal can move a 1,400 square foot house in Manatee County by more than the entire exemption increase is worth in a year. Roof age, four-point inspection findings, wind mitigation, claims history on the property rather than the owner, the carrier deciding to stop writing in this county at all. I have watched a policy double on a house that had nothing wrong with it except the calendar.
Maintenance is the second line, and it is the one people forget because it does not arrive as a bill with a due date. A 2005 roof does not care what the legislature did. Neither does a fourteen-year-old air handler, nor a seawall, nor the irrigation pump. Those costs get heavier every year in Florida, and the exemption change does nothing to them.
So the honest arithmetic is this: the amendment gives an owner a real but modest annual reduction, and the market is handing back increases that are often larger. That is not an argument against the amendment. It is an argument against pricing a purchase off the savings.
What I do with it in a file
When I run numbers for a buyer, I never put a projected exemption increase into the affordability calculation. I underwrite the current tax bill, the current insurance quote, the current HOA, and a maintenance reserve I estimate from the age of the systems and the condition of the roof. If the deal only works because of a legislative change that has not reached the tax roll yet, the deal is too tight.
I do the reverse for sellers. I do not lead with the exemption expansion as a reason to buy my listing, because the buyer's lender will not underwrite it either, and because a buyer who has been told a number will be lower and then sees the first escrow analysis will remember who told them.
For owners already in place, the practical step is not complicated. Confirm the exemption is properly recorded on the property, and confirm it before the March 1 deadline for the year in question. I have seen homestead exemptions unrecorded on properties owned for years, quietly costing the owner four figures annually. That is money sitting on the table with no lawsuit, no negotiation, and no one to blame but a form that never got filed.
The larger point about policy and price
The legislature can change the tax line. It cannot change the storm line, the insurance market, or the age of the roof. Amendment 3 is real relief, and I will take it. But I tell buyers the same thing I tell them about interest rates: buy the house you can carry at today's cost, not the house that only works if something outside your control improves.
If you want to sit down with your actual tax bill, your actual insurance declarations page and the age of every major system in a property you are considering, bring them to me. That conversation is more useful than any projection I could hand you about 2027.
