MarketNovember 17, 2026

Insurance rate relief is finally arriving, but Manatee and Sarasota buyers face a split market

While over 800,000 Florida homeowners see insurance rate cuts, local buyers are navigating a market where cash purchases are rising and single-family inventory remains tight.

Divina Greenberg, J.D., CIPS · Florida Real Estate Broker

I have spent the last few days reviewing the latest market data for our region, and the most significant shift I am seeing is the divergence between cash and financed buyers. According to the October 2026 report from the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee, while overall sales have remained relatively stable, we are seeing a 5.1 percent increase in cash transactions alongside a 6.3 percent decline in financed purchases. This tells me that the cost of borrowing is continuing to weigh on the average buyer, even as we see some relief in other areas of homeownership costs. ## Insurance relief is finally here for many homeowners. One of the most frequent questions I get from clients is whether the insurance crisis has hit a ceiling. There is finally some concrete news on this front. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation reported that more than 824,300 homeowners are receiving property insurance rate decreases this month, with some cuts reaching as high as 12.1 percent. While this does not erase the massive premium hikes we have seen over the last few years, it is a necessary correction. I always advise my clients to price the insurance premium before we even write an offer, and these decreases are a welcome change for those looking at renewals or new policies. ## The split between new construction and resale. In Manatee County, new construction remains a major factor in our inventory. During the first week of November, new construction accounted for 20.4 percent of all closed residential sales. When I look at the data for Parrish and Lakewood Ranch, I see that buyers are often choosing between a brand-new home with builder incentives and a resale property that might have a better location but higher maintenance needs. It is vital to look at the actual offer terms, as builder incentives can often mask the true cost of the home compared to a resale property. ## Impact fees and the cost of development. We are still waiting on a decision from the 12th Judicial Circuit Court regarding the Manatee County impact fee lawsuit. As someone who has built fourteen homes in this county, I know that these fees are a significant component of the final price tag for any new build. Developers are watching this closely, especially after a similar case in Palm Coast was decided in favor of developers earlier this fall. If the court rules against the county, it could eventually lead to a shift in how new subdivisions are priced and brought to market. ## What this means if you are buying or selling. If you are buying, do not let the countywide median price fool you. In Manatee County, the median sale price for single-family homes was $548,000 for the first week of November, while condos and villas were significantly lower at $255,000 and $267,500 respectively. You must look at your specific property type and neighborhood to understand your leverage. If you are selling, remember that we are seeing a 96.9 percent average sale-to-last-list-price ratio. This is not a discount from your original asking price, but rather a reflection of where the market settled after your most recent price adjustment. If your home has been sitting on the market, look at the competition in your specific price band rather than the overall county averages. This information is intended for general guidance and does not constitute legal advice for your specific transaction. Please bring your contract to me for a line-by-line review before you sign anything.