MarketNovember 18, 2026

Market shifts and the new homestead exemption are changing how we price local homes

As the homestead exemption grows and market activity moderates, I am seeing a clear divide between cash and financed buyers in Manatee and Sarasota counties.

Divina Greenberg, J.D., CIPS · Florida Real Estate Broker

I have spent the last few days reviewing the October market data, and it is clear that our local real estate landscape is no longer moving in a single direction. While the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee reported that overall sales remained relatively steady, the underlying data shows a distinct split between cash and financed buyers, according to the October 2026 market report. Across both counties, single-family closed sales declined 2.4 percent year-over-year, but cash purchases actually increased by 5.1 percent, while transactions involving financing dropped by 6.3 percent. This tells me that those relying on mortgages are facing a much tougher environment than those with liquid capital. With the 30-year mortgage average recently hovering around 7.18 percent, as noted in recent housing intelligence reports, it is no surprise that financed buyers are pulling back. I always advise my clients to run a full insurance and tax projection before making an offer, as these costs now represent a significant portion of the monthly payment. Speaking of taxes, the recent passage of Amendment 3, which will raise the statewide homestead exemption to $250,000 over the next two years, is a major development that will influence long-term holding costs for primary residents, as reported by Florida Trend. While this is welcome news for homeowners, it is important to remember that insurance remains the other half of the equation. There is some relief on the horizon, with over 824,300 Florida homeowners receiving rate decreases this month, according to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. I have seen firsthand how these fluctuations impact a buyer's ability to qualify, so I treat insurance quotes as a critical contingency in every contract I draft. In Manatee County, we are also seeing the impact of development costs and regulatory changes. The county updated its impact fee schedule as of September 9, 2026, as documented by the Manatee County Development Services Department, which continues to influence the pricing of new construction. New builds accounted for 42.5 percent of closings in late October, according to recent market snapshots, meaning that a large portion of our inventory is tied directly to these shifting fee structures. If you are looking at a new subdivision in Parrish or Palmetto, you must verify which fee schedule applies to your specific lot, as these costs are almost always passed on to the buyer. What this means if you are buying or selling: If you are selling, do not rely on broad countywide medians to set your price. The market is highly segmented; while single-family homes at higher price points are seeing activity, lower-priced segments are experiencing a buildup in inventory. In Manatee County, for instance, active listings priced between $300,000 and $399,999 increased by 17.9 percent, per the latest RASM report. If your home falls in that range, you are competing with more options than you were a year ago. For buyers, the increase in inventory is an opportunity to negotiate, especially in the condo and townhome sectors where supply is more balanced. Always look at the days-on-market for your specific neighborhood rather than the county average. If a property has been sitting, check the history of price adjustments; hundreds of properties are still recording downward adjustments each week, as tracked in recent market snapshots. This information is intended for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice for your specific transaction. Real estate contracts are binding legal documents, so please bring your contract to me for a line-by-line review before you sign anything.